Greatest NFL Quarterbacks
There have been many great quarterbacks, but only a handful can qualify for SCL's Greatest of All Time.

Instructions
SCL Rankings - this is the order that we rank the greatest. For our reasoning click on the "?".

Your Rankings - to rank the greatest in the order you think best:
  1. Click and drag each box up or down the list.
  2. Click "Vote" at the bottom of the list
  3. Click "Back" on the Thank You page and then REFRESH your browser to see how your vote impacted the rankings.

NOTE: Javascript must be turned on.

SCL Ranking
  • 1 Dan Marino
  • 2 Joe Montana
  • 3 Brett Favre
  • 4 John Elway
  • 5 Johnny Unitas
  • 6 Peyton Manning
  • 7 Tom Brady
  • 8 Steve Young
  • 9 Warren Moon
  • 10 Fran Tarkington
  • 11 Dan Fouts
  • 12 Troy Aikman
  • 13 Bart Starr
  • 14 Terry Bradshaw
  • 15 Jim Kelly
  • 16 Roger Staubach
  • 17 Otto Graham
  • 18 Sammy Baugh
  • 19 Sid Luckman
  • 20 Ken Stabler

Others Receiving Consideration: Joe Namath

Member Ranking

League Ranking
  • 1 
    Joe Montana
  • 2 
    Dan Marino
  • 3 
    Johnny Unitas
  • 4 
    John Elway
  • 5 
    Peyton Manning
  • 6 
    Tom Brady
  • 7 
    Brett Favre
  • 8 
    Steve Young
  • 9 
    Roger Staubach
  • 10 
    Bart Starr
  • 11 
    Troy Aikman
  • 12 
    Terry Bradshaw
  • 13 
    Sammy Baugh
  • 14 
    Fran Tarkington
  • 15 
    Jim Kelly
  • 16 
    Otto Graham
  • 17 
    Warren Moon
  • 18 
    Dan Fouts
  • 19 
    Ken Stabler
  • 20 
    Sid Luckman